Skip to main content

Top 10 Dynasty WR Rookie Rankings: Emerging Stars of Tomorrow


As the NFL landscape continues to evolve, so does the talent pool entering the league, especially at the wide receiver position. Each year, new rookies burst onto the scene, bringing with them a blend of athleticism, skill, and potential that captivates fans and fantasy football enthusiasts alike. Here, we delve into my top 10 dynasty wide receiver rookie rankings, highlighting the players poised to make a significant impact in the years to come.


1. Marvin Harrison Jr.


At the top of the list stands Marvin Harrison Jr., a formidable talent standing at 6’3″ and weighing in at 204 pounds. With his impressive physical attributes and refined route-running ability, Harrison Jr. is primed to become a Day 1 WR1 for any team lucky enough to draft him. 


His knack for winning contested catches, 16th ranked according to PFF, and his proficiency in the deep passing game, 3rd in Deep catches and 5th in deep yards, make him a versatile weapon reminiscent of NFL greats like AJ Green. From a fantasy perspective, he simply has the highest floor as well as the ceiling of the group. 


2. Malik Nabers


Coming in at number two is Malik Nabers, a dynamic playmaker with the versatility to excel both inside and outside.


 Nabers’ ability to create separation and make big plays downfield, 2nd in deep catches and 4th in deep yards, earns him comparisons to Garrett Wilson, showcasing his potential to become a complete WR1 at the next level. Containing the kind of ability that should make him an elite Redraft value this year as well as Dynasty. 


3. Rome Odunze


Rome Odunze enters the rankings at number three, boasting elite athleticism, 6’3 212 lbs with 4.45 40-yard speed, and ball skills that set him apart from his peers. 


As a prototypical X receiver, Odunze has the size and agility to dominate single coverage and make contested catches, ranked 1st with 20 contested catches, at an elite level, drawing comparisons to DeAndre Hopkins. The top 3 prospects this year all possess WR1 overall fantasy potential throughout their careers. 


4. Ladd McConkey


Ladd McConkey earns my fourth spot with his precise route-running and reliable hands, only 2 drops last year, making him a valuable asset in any passing attack. With surprising speed, 4.39 40-yard dash time, and explosiveness, McConkey has the potential to thrive as a movable chess piece on the field. 


Ladd displays almost effortless smoothness on the field reminiscent of Chris Olave. He could easily anchor nearly any wide receiver room and be an early producer. 


5. Brian Thomas Jr.


Brian Thomas Jr. rounds out the top five with his explosive, 4.33 40-yard dash time, downfield ability, and the incredible size of 6’5 188 lbs. 


While his raw route-running may need refinement, Thomas Jr.’s knack for making big plays, 2nd in deep yards, and scoring touchdowns, 17 last season, presents undeniable potential. Likening him to Martavis Bryant to illustrate his extreme boom-or-bust fantasy value.


6. Adonai Mitchell


Adonai Mitchell’s physicality, 6’3 205 lbs, and deep threat potential, 4.34 40-yard dash, land him at number six on the list. 


Despite needing to refine his route-running and questions about his overall collegiate production, Mitchell possesses all the tools to develop into a WR1 in the NFL. His athleticism and red zone prowess, 11 receiving touchdowns in 2023, leads me to draw comparisons to George Pickens. If he can avoid the QB and OC pitfalls that Pickens has had to endure, Mitchell should be a weekly fantasy starter. 


7. Xavier Worthy


Xavier Worthy’s elite speed, record-breaking 4.21 40-yard time, and quickness make him a dangerous weapon on the field, capable of stretching defenses and making plays in the open field. 


At 5’11 165 lbs, there are natural limitations in play strength. Capping potential production in contested situations, ranked 218th, or red zone consistency, 5 receiving touchdowns last year, least in career. His natural burst, 1.49 10-yard split, should allow him to overcome size with separation to beat corners on the perimeter. 


Worthy’s tendency to use his speed rather than his quickness is more reminiscent of DeSean Jackson than the common Tyreek Hill comparison. Either way, this will be a tantalizing fantasy prospect whose NFL draft projection late in the 1st round may gift Worthy an elite offensive destination. Therefore top 12 positional fantasy potential early in his career. 


8. Troy Franklin


Troy Franklin’s explosive playmaking ability, 8th on deep catches and a 4.41 40-yard time, earns him a spot at number eight on the list. An even more impressive ability when considering the checkdown-natured quarterback he played with in Bo Nix.

Concerns with Franklin’s hands, 9 drops last season, and below-average contested catch production, ranked 118th, given his 6’2 176 lb size restricts him from entering a higher wide receiver tier. 


Franklin displays solid route-running ability in a program that typically limits their wide receiver trees. However, the key to his development will be contingent on consistency and the ability to fight off stronger corners at the line of scrimmage. Lack of physical play at times allows defenders to gain position negating his prototype size. Still, the package of tools needed to be productive at the NFL level resides in Franklin. 


Franklin has the potential to develop into a reliable target in the NFL, comparable to Calvin Ridley. Does not play with the elite level athleticism as the tier 1 wide receivers, but certainly possesses all the tools necessary to win consistently at the next level as a WR2.


9. Keon Coleman


Keon Coleman’s size, 6’3 213 lbs, and body control make him a formidable presence on the field, particularly in contested catch situations where he ranked 42nd. While his speed may not be elite, 4.61 40-yard time, Coleman’s route-running and versatility are comparable to Michael Pittman. 


Like Pittman, Coleman’s NFL and fantasy potential will be contingent on a couple of factors. The right fit will allow him to play inside often, and with volume. The splash plays will be rare for Coleman’s production. However, his sure-fire hands, only 2 drops last year, and red zone prowess, 18 receiving touchdowns over the past 2 seasons, could carry him to WR2 level upside. 


10. Brenden Rice


Rounding out the top 10 is Brenden Rice, a smooth route-runner with reliable hands, only 2 drops, and a knack for finding the end zone with 12 touchdowns last season. While he may not possess elite speed, 4.5 40-yard time, Rice’s ability to use his body and make strong catches likens him to Allen Robinson, making him a potentially valuable steal in drafts. 


His draft capital is currently projected as a late-day 2 or early-day 3 selection. This draft value would be sufficient for Rice to have a legitimate opportunity to compete for significant playing time sooner rather than later. 

It bodes well that his work ethic and fundamentals make him a coach’s dream. 


Rice possesses all the intangibles of an offense’s reliable safety blanket in the most crucial moments. Chain movers and red zone production correlate well with fantasy assets with high floors. 


As these talented rookies prepare to embark on their NFL journey, the future of the wide receiver position looks brighter than ever. With a blend of size, speed, and skill, these young stars are poised to make a significant impact on the league for years to come, captivating fans and fantasy football enthusiasts alike with their electrifying play on the field.

This article was written by Dan Mader @DanMaderFF. Come join Fantasy Football Advice Network for more content discussions.